Project and Funding Statuses

August Update on DOE Award Terminations Litigation

By Tarak Shah, S1/S4 alum; Gabriel Daly, GC alum; and Katherine Christopher with Lawyers for Good Government

August 17, 2026

Over the past fifteen months, the U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) financial assistance recipients have navigated a complex administrative and legal environment surrounding federal grant terminations, as discussed in the DOE Alumni Network’s Innovation Interrupted report, and Substack posts about the lawsuits, the “Retain/Modify” list, and the Hydrogen and DAC hubs.

DOE’s terminations sparked headlines again last month after the agency admitted to terminating awards “based solely” on whether the awardee was headquartered in a ‘blue state’ in a formal court filing. DOE went further by saying the termination decisions were not driven by "any programmatic, statutory, cost-reduction, or performance-based factor."

The filing received widespread coverage in national news outlets, including The New York Times, Associated Press, and NBC News. In the wake of these revelations, on July 30, 2026, Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee Ranking Member Martin Heinrich and Senate Appropriations Ranking Member Patty Murray, along with 35 colleagues, submitted a letter to DOE Secretary Chris Wright and Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Director Russ Vought requesting the formal restoration of targeted award funds. In addition, on August 4, 2026, House Science Committee Ranking Member Zoe Lofgren and Subcommittee Ranking Member Gabe Amo formally referred Secretary Chris Wright to the U.S. Department of Justice for criminal prosecution for lying under oath, during his June 10, 2026 testimony, where he testified that “no decisions were made on politics.”

Below is an updated timeline recap of how we arrived at this moment and a status update of the seven major active lawsuits challenging DOE's actions.

The Timeline

Based on what we’ve learned through key court documents, we now have a clearer understanding of the timeline of events associated with the award terminations.

  • May 2025: DOE issued a Secretarial Order titled “Secretarial Policy on Ensuring Responsibility for Financial Assistance” and initiated a broad financial assistance review, and two weeks later, canceled 24 Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations (OCED) awards totaling approximately $3 billion.

  • Summer 2025: The agency’s Portfolio Review Process (PRP) Committee “reviewed” thousands of active financial assistance awards across various program offices through an opaque process lacking transparency.

  • September 2025: DOE submitted a list of 624 awards under review to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) with a recommendation to terminate them.

  • October 1, 2025: DOE issued mass termination notices covering 321 awards valued at approximately $7.56 billion. This is the subset of awards from the September list that were located in 17 ‘blue states.’

  • April 14, 2026: DOE transmitted a "Retain/Modify" list to Congress containing 1,951 awards valued at $23.5 billion. This list only includes 18 of the awards terminated on October 1st, 2025.

  • August 2026: The vast majority of awardees who challenged their terminations have not yet received a final determination on their Informal Dispute Resolution request. Some large projects that were included on the April 2026 “retain/modify” list do not appear to be on a path to be functionally retained, as discussed in Alumni Network Substack posts and the Hydrogen hubs (written by OCED Alum Keith Boyea) and DAC hubs (written by FECM Alum Grant Faber).

An Overview of Key Active Cases

Six lawsuits currently involve the legal boundaries of DOE’s termination authority. The claims raised by these cases span administrative procedure, constitutional claims, and contract law.

1. St. Paul v. Wright (U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia)

  • Context: Filed in November 2025, this suit served as the first challenge to DOE’s October 1st tranche of grant cancellations. Five awardees, with seven awards worth $27.6 million brought suit.

  • Key Rulings: In January 2026, the Court ruled that DOE’s action violated the equal protection guarantee of the Fifth Amendment’s due process clause, ordering the terminations of the plaintiff grantees’ grants vacated.  The Court’s decision was based on DOE’s on-the-record admission that “a primary reason” for the October award terminations was “whether the grantee was located in a “Blue State.” The court determined constituted impermissible geographic and political discrimination. This case established a clear precedent that DOE’s October 1 terminations were unconstitutional.

  • Current Status: The statutory deadline to file a notice of appeal expired on June 2, 2026, without DOE taking action. The reinstatements for named plaintiffs are legally binding and final.

2. AIChE v. Wright (U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia)

  • Context: Filed in March 2026 by the American Institute of Chemical Engineers (AIChE) alongside six other grantee institutions representing 11 specific awards worth $63.2 million.

  • Key Rulings: On June 11, 2026, the Court, based on that same Judge’s decision in the St. Paul case, entered a stipulated judgment fully vacating the termination of all 11 awards.

  • Current Status: The government’s deadline to appeal was August 12, 2026. Because the government did not appeal, the district court's June 2026 judgment, vacating the terminations of the grants at issue in that case, is now final.

3. Thakur v. Trump (U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California)

  • Context: Originally filed in June 2025 on behalf of University of California researchers against several federal agencies. The DOE portion of this putative class action lawsuit encompasses 13 awards terminated on October 1, 2025, totaling $1.26 billion including the ARCHES California Hydrogen Hub.

  • Current Status: Following the widely-covered filing of DOE’s political discrimination stipulations on July 15, 2026, the discovery phase closed. Summary judgment briefing is occurring throughout the summer, with a hearing scheduled for October 2026.

4. California et al. v. Wright (U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California)

  • Context: Filed in February 2026 by 13 state Attorneys General, this lawsuit overlaps factually and legally with Thakur in part, challenging the defunding of state-backed infrastructure like ARCHES.

  • Key Rulings: DOE moved to sever and transfer most of the state’s claims to the U.S. Court of Federal Claims (CFC), arguing they were contract disputes in disguise. The judge denied DOE’s motion to transfer, ruling that the claims arise from a shared, operative nucleus of administrative action (the May 2025 Secretarial Order) rather than isolated contract breaches.

  • Current Status: The Court recently established a revised discovery and motions schedule. Fact and expert discovery will run through December 2026, with cross-motions for Summary Judgment scheduled from January through April 2027.

5. Sustainability Institute v. Trump (U.S. District Court for the District of South Carolina)

  • Context: Filed in May 2025, this case challenges systemic funding impoundments across multi-agency programs authorized under the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), including DOE’s IRA Section 50131 Building Energy Codes program, alongside EPA and DOT initiatives.

  • Key Rulings: On June 11, 2026, the District Court issued a summary judgment ruling holding that EPA unlawfully terminated its Environmental and Climate Justice (ECJ) program.

  • Current Status: The specific challenge to DOE’s constructive termination of the Building Energy Codes program remains unresolved and is pending final summary judgment briefing.

6. Sublime Systems v. USA (U.S. Court of Federal Claims)

  • Context: Filed in March 2026 by cement technology company, Sublime Systems, following the cancellation of an $87 million grant awarded to construct a manufacturing facility. While other active lawsuits challenge DOE’s actions under administrative law and constitutional grounds, this suit represents the first contract-based claim arising from the terminations, and seeks $2 billion in damages. 

  • Current Status: On August 12, 2026, the Court rejected the government’s motion to dismiss the case, and the case is now in the discovery phase. 

Other Legal and Regulatory Actions to Keep on Your Radar

State of New Jersey v. Office of Management and Budget (U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts)

  • Context: Filed in June 2025, a group of 20 states and Washington, D.C. challenged the Trump Administration’s ability to cancel awards based on the government’s changed priorities, under 2 CFR 200.340(a)(4), which allows for agencies to terminate an award if it “no longer effectuates program goals or agency priorities.” This Termination Clause is the justification that DOE gave in the vast majority of award terminations in 2025. The plaintiffs in the New Jersey case sought a “preenforcement declaration,” curtailing agencies’ abilities to terminate current and future awards based on new agency priorities that were not identified at the time of the award. They did not seek relief related to grants already terminated using the Termination Clause. 

  • Current status: On July 17, 2026, the Court granted the Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment, finding that the Termination Clause does not permit agencies to terminate grants based on program goals and agency priorities identified after grants were awarded. The Court concluded that 2 CFR 200.340(a) must instead refer to a specific set of goals of priorities, those in place at the time of the initial award, and that the Termination Clause may only be invoked in the future if an award is failing to effectuate those (fixed) goals and priorities.

City and County of San Francisco v. Wright (U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California)

  • Context: Filed in June 2026, San Francisco is challenging DEI-related grant conditions that DOE imposed as part of an April 2026 revision to the agency’s standard award terms and conditions. 

  • Current Status: Given the newness of this case, it is still in a preliminary stage of litigation.

Regulatory Developments: Proposed Revisions to 2 C.F.R. 200

Beyond individual court proceedings, OMB published a proposed rule on May 29, 2026, revising the Uniform Guidance for Federal Financial Assistance (2 C.F.R. 200).

Key provisions of the proposal include:

  • Transitioning federal financial assistance framework from agency guidance into a uniform regulatory structure.

  • Standardizing agency authority to modify, pause, or terminate financial assistance awards based on agency priorities.

  • Codifying broad administrative discretion over project scope and performance criteria.

DOE alum Janie Thompson (CI Alum) wrote about the implications for DOE grantees in a recent post on the Alumni Network’s Substack. The public comment period closed on July 13, 2026, receiving approximately 500,000 public submissions. OMB’s previously published schedule anticipated interagency review through August, and sought a target effective date of October 1, 2026. Given the number of comments, which require review, pending Congressional actions, and potential legal action, that schedule may slip.

The DOE Alumni Network will continue monitoring case dockets and outlay data as these matters progress toward fall hearings.

###

This piece was drafted by trusted and vetted alumni of the U.S. Department of Energy. Any views and opinions expressed are that of the author(s) and do not reflect those of the DOE Alumni Network.